Jump to content

Register Now

Posted Image
Welcome guest, thank you for visiting the MainelySubarus forums! Register today to enjoy the benefits of:

* Informational updates and news concerning the latest Subaru related information, updates, recalls, and more.
* Share and track your Subaru and the unique modifications you have done with our custom Members Garage.
* Finally make friends and have fun discussions in regards to Subaru's and modifications.
* Post and make new threads in a safe and fully moderated environment without the worry of harassment like on other larger forums.
* Users can share their insights and opinions on stores, purchases, and vendors.
* And many many other benefits, register today to experience them all!


Photo

09 STI Winter Tire Help / Rims?

- - - - -

  • Please log in to reply
15 replies to this topic

#1
OFFLINE   JessicaScooby

JessicaScooby
  • Member
  • 5 posts
  • Joined 28-July 13
  • Vehicle:Subaru STI 2009

Hey everybody,

 

So, I am in an endless debate with my husband regarding winter tires and rims.  I need HELP!  My husband says to get all season, but I know that is just wrong.  I need winter tires.  Right?  And what do you recommend?  Blizzaks are expensive but the best?  Any others I should consider?

 

Also, should I get rims for the winter tires, or just put them on my current rims and then wait until spring and get a new set of rims for my summer tires?  (delay a little cost there, anyway)

 

Any advice would be greatly appreciated... it's time to bite the bullet, snow is on the ground!

 

Thank you!!

Jess





#2
OFFLINE   drvsdwz

drvsdwz

    DRiVe SiDeWayZ

  • +Super Moderator
  • 3,873 posts
  • Joined 24-March 10
  • Real Name:Justin
  • Vehicle:2007 Subaru Outback 2.5i Basic
Garage View Garage

it's always a debate, but the best way to go about it is to get a set of winter tires. all seasons can get you by, but have no where near the amount of grip that any winter tire has.

 

If it were me, and you can afford it, find some 17inch wheels and have the winter tires mounted on those. You will spend almost the same if you were to get winter tires alone for the 18 inch wheels.

 

The winterforce tires are a cheaper alternative snow tire, if traction is really what you are looking for.


Justin


____________________________________________________________________________________________
 


#3
OFFLINE   CoupedUpSubie

CoupedUpSubie

    FWD-FTW

  • Member
  • 2,089 posts
  • Joined 17-February 10
  • LocationWoolwich
  • Real Name:Bryan
  • Vehicle:2013 BRZ Limited, 1995 Impreza Coupe 1.8L
Garage View Garage
I think most on here would recommend a set of dedicated snow tires. Hankook iPikes are a good choice, blizzaks are good as well. I have yet to really find out how my Dunlop WinterSport 3Ds work on the BRZ. Another good tire is the General altimax arctic.

To backup what Justin said, 17" wheels for snows is a good idea. The extra half inch of sidewall can help in the snow but shouldn't cut down handling much if any at all.

Edited by CoupedUpSubie, 01 December 2013 - 09:06 PM.


#4
OFFLINE   brighton

brighton

    Rally Fluffer

  • Member
  • 1,236 posts
  • Joined 06-April 08
  • LocationBridgton, Maine
  • Real Name:Tim
  • Vehicle:06 T4R V8
Garage View Garage
http://www.tirerack....ay.jsp?ttid=116

It is like having a miata tossed at the windsheild of your car compared to hitting a pile of hay bales in the road


06 TR4 V8

Subarus from my past:
08 FSXT
06 STI
02 WRX

Ham Callsign:KB1VUW

#5
OFFLINE   SoMeWRX

SoMeWRX
  • Member
  • 445 posts
  • Joined 18-September 11
  • LocationPortland
  • Real Name:Dylan
  • Vehicle:2010 Forester XT
Garage View Garage

Snows! Do it, you wont regret. I heard your husband wanted to get you some nice ones for christmas...

 

Ditto on the 17 inch wheel too rather than wrapping those 18s. You will save money remounting every year that way too.


2010 Forester XT Limited - Cobb AP Stage 1

2007 WRX Limited - Invidia turboback, K&N, Cobb AP Stage 2, Rally Armors - SOLD

2008 Yamaha V-Star 1100 - Vance and Hines pipes, black on black on black on black on chrome - SOLD

2000 VW TDI - Stage 1 tune, mufflerless 2.5" catback, K&N ccai, vr6 clutch kit, Bosch T4 .216 fuel injectors, EGR delete, H&R/bilstein sport kit, Autometer column gauges, lots of accent mods, 17" exors...and still 48 mpg - SOLD

1965 Plymouth Barracuda - swapped 318, 727, Red Box ignition, Edelbrock intake mani, headers, 2-pot MC, other fun stuff - SOLD


My couch pulls out but I don't.

#6
OFFLINE   jojo69

jojo69
  • Member
  • 568 posts
  • Joined 08-September 12
  • LocationWhitefield
  • Vehicle:wrb GR wrx
Garage View Garage
I've had excellent results with Altimax and they were a lot cheaper than the others like blizzaks or Xi2/3. That being said, past the 2d season, they didn't do as good in deep snow. as when I first got them. That being said, blizzaks + steal 16 rims are a affordable and efficient combo! A more expensive would be ws70 + dedicated 17 rim (or 16) :) I'm currently running same setup as last year except this time with xi3 i got at the end of last year so they never saw snow yet. Can't wait to see how they perform! keep up posted on your decision Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201

#7
OFFLINE   drvsdwz

drvsdwz

    DRiVe SiDeWayZ

  • +Super Moderator
  • 3,873 posts
  • Joined 24-March 10
  • Real Name:Justin
  • Vehicle:2007 Subaru Outback 2.5i Basic
Garage View Garage

I've had excellent results with Altimax and they were a lot cheaper than the others like blizzaks or Xi2/3. That being said, past the 2d season, they didn't do as good in deep snow. as when I first got them. That being said, blizzaks + steal 16 rims are a affordable and efficient combo! A more expensive would be ws70 + dedicated 17 rim (or 16) :) I'm currently running same setup as last year except this time with xi3 i got at the end of last year so they never saw snow yet. Can't wait to see how they perform! keep up posted on your decision Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201

 

 

can't fit 16's on them big brembos


Justin


____________________________________________________________________________________________
 


#8
OFFLINE   jojo69

jojo69
  • Member
  • 568 posts
  • Joined 08-September 12
  • LocationWhitefield
  • Vehicle:wrb GR wrx
Garage View Garage

I've had excellent results with Altimax and they were a lot cheaper than the others like blizzaks or Xi2/3. That being said, past the 2d season, they didn't do as good in deep snow. as when I first got them. That being said, blizzaks + steal 16 rims are a affordable and efficient combo! A more expensive would be ws70 + dedicated 17 rim (or 16) :) I'm currently running same setup as last year except this time with xi3 i got at the end of last year so they never saw snow yet. Can't wait to see how they perform! keep up posted on your decision Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201
 
 
can't fit 16's on them big brembos


gotta suck having an sti! ;-)

Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201

#9
OFFLINE   Nigel Prodrive

Nigel Prodrive

    Dirt surfer

  • Member
  • 3,741 posts
  • Joined 11-September 08
  • Real Name:Dave aka Nigel
  • Vehicle:Snowball the 00 RS sedan or Larry the Lariat F-250, or Wolfie the 911S
Garage View Garage

go w/17s el cheapo wheels and narrowest snows that will fit. the "minus one" setup for your car is 17" wheels with 225-45 size tires. search Tire Rack, they've got the goods.


!!! L3-/jump into straight @ T into beaver bog

#10
OFFLINE   i-wagon

i-wagon
  • Member
  • 5,135 posts
  • Joined 22-July 09
  • Real Name:Matt
  • Vehicle:2007 2.5i wagon
+1 for narrower, Goodyear ultra grip winter are very good all aground and inexpensive at the wallet world

#11
OFFLINE   JessicaScooby

JessicaScooby
  • Member
  • 5 posts
  • Joined 28-July 13
  • Vehicle:Subaru STI 2009

Thanks, everybody!  I'm still wrestling with the decisions here!  And I need to do something soon with all this snow out there!  This is where I am at:

 

Option # 1:  Blizzak WS-70 225/50/17 on the Motegi MR118 rims.   ($1500ish total). 

 

Option # 2:  Put Blizzaks on my current 18" rims since I don't love them, and then get rims I really love for the rest of the year since they are on the car more  (and current tires on there are done anyway). 

 

Thoughts??  Will 18" blizzaks not be as good in the snow as 17"?



#12
OFFLINE   JessicaScooby

JessicaScooby
  • Member
  • 5 posts
  • Joined 28-July 13
  • Vehicle:Subaru STI 2009

Now I'm thinking of the Nokian Hakka R2... they sound amaaazing. 



#13
OFFLINE   jojo69

jojo69
  • Member
  • 568 posts
  • Joined 08-September 12
  • LocationWhitefield
  • Vehicle:wrb GR wrx
Garage View Garage
From my research, Nokian are supposed to be the best... but can't remember if super expensive. why not Nokian on steel? Nokian will maximize performace and the steel rim will reduce the snow cake in your wheel wells plus rims in winter get nasty/salty/muddy as soon as you go outside, so it's a constant battle to clean'em up. 18's will work in the snow, but as others pointed out, 17 or 16 will provide more clearance and more ability to cut into the snow, so better performance. No need to have surface contact as in summer tires. From the options you mentionned, I'd go with option 2, ws70 + current setup. They are excellent tires and that leaves you time to think on a great rim down the road. Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201

Edited by jojo69, 17 December 2013 - 07:28 AM.


#14
OFFLINE   blehhh

blehhh
  • Member
  • 344 posts
  • Joined 05-October 12
  • LocationWestbrook
  • Real Name:Benny V
  • Vehicle:'12 WRX Hatch Torqued Performance Stage III
Garage View Garage

2014 STI owner is already looking to buy these, but if that falls through, I have a set of studded General Altimax Arctic 205s on 17" steelies. Might not clear brembos without spacers, but yeah... They were on my Mazda for like 4k miles. Very healthy.



#15
OFFLINE   JessicaScooby

JessicaScooby
  • Member
  • 5 posts
  • Joined 28-July 13
  • Vehicle:Subaru STI 2009

Thanks, everybody.  I'm getting my Blizzaks put on my current wheels tomorrow (Nokians sound incredible but hard to get and $$$.. maybe next time).  So now you can all help me start deciding on summer tires and rims that I'll purchase in the spring! :-D 



#16
OFFLINE   brycetron

brycetron
  • Member
  • 189 posts
  • Joined 18-December 13
  • LocationWaterville, ME
  • Real Name:Brycent
  • Vehicle:2011 STI
Garage View Garage

Seems like you made your decision but ive been pondering this on my 2011 STI.  Snow tires are definitely the way to go and Blizzaks are king.  Ive had a set, love them.

 

I really dont want to buy 18" snow tires for my stock wheels.  I think its the 05-07 STI wheels are 17" and bolt right on.  They are also narrower than my '11's wheels.  Not sure about '09.  that's the route ill eventually go.  Find older used 17" STI wheels and slap blizzaks on them.  win win.

 

 

As far as summer wheels and tires.  Im gonna get some 18x9.5 or 18x10 enkie rpf1's with some 255 or 265 ventus.  Lotta debate on wether or not you need a spacer up front. Havnt done a ton of research but the threads ive found show no definitive answer.  definitely need to roll the rears which i fine.  

 

depends what your plans are for summer.  Just something kinda grippy that looks nice or a real aggressive sticky setup.


Edited by brycetron, 22 December 2013 - 12:24 PM.






1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users