I think where I struggle with this (highly frowned upon in the design community...but don't worry even as a design professional, I'm not judging) crowd sourcing logo design is that you've already established a "brand" with the logo that is on the banner at the top of the site. In order for there to be a brand consistency, having the decals and the site match would be more successful. Are you guys planning on having things (site, logo wear, business cards, etc) match up after a design is chosen? What was the cause for the change?