Different oils work differently in each individual car. The best way to find the oil for yours is to try a few out, and send in samples to Blackstone Labs. You're not going to "damage" your engine as long as you use name brand quality oils.
Like someone has already stated in this thread, Mobil1 is known for oil consumption issues but they aren't limited to subaru. Mobil1 is a very "thin" oil, try putting some in a cup next to say Rotella T "thick" or Amsoil "medium". They both may have the same "weights" but their formula at room temp has a different "thickness" to it. I'd call it viscosity, but that term would pertain to the weight (5w-30 etc..)
I would stick with the factory recommended weight for the testing. I tried Mobil1, Motul, and Amsoil. None of the oils did poorly at all, but out of those three my engine seemed to like the Amsoil best. Combine this with my hatred of Mobil1 hehe and needless to say, I'll be running Amsoil 5w-30 unless I find something else that works well. The next oil I'd like to try out is Pentosin 5w-30. It's a European diesel oil that I had great luck with in my VW/Audi high performance apps.
-----Added 8/22/2009 at 07:11:19-----
I was running rotella 5w40 but switched to amsoil 5w30. They are both awesome I just think the amsoil will be a little better performance wise and it sketched me out running diesal truck oil in my car.
just an FYI, diesel truck oils generally have higher API service ratings than gas motor oils. This means they're a better quality oil with less shear and the ability to withstand a lot more abuse. Rotella is a great diesel oil, but for gas engines it seems a bit thick for me. I'll get that Pentosin coming and see how she likes it. It has a consistency very close to castrol syntec, but carries that higher quality API service rating suited for diesel and is a true full synthetic, not a hydrocracked semi-synthetic like castrol syntec.